Fixed vs. Variable? 3 vs. 5 Year? Navigating Your Post-Rate-Cut Mortgage Maze

Fixed vs. Variable? 3 vs. 5 Year? Navigating Your Post-Rate-Cut Mortgage Maze
June 11, 2024

The Bank of Canada's (BOC) recent interest rate cut sent ripples through the mortgage market, leaving Canadians with a crucial decision: fixed or variable rate mortgage? But the options extend beyond this initial choice. Let's delve into the pros and cons of various lock-in terms, including both fixed and variable rates, to help you navigate this dynamic landscape and choose the best option for your current situation.

Understanding Your Lock-In Options

Fixed vs. Variable Rates

  • Fixed Rates: Offer stability and predictability in your monthly payments. You lock in an interest rate for the term, shielding yourself from interest rate fluctuations. This provides peace of mind for budgeting but might mean missing out on potential future decreases (around 68% of Canadians opted for fixed rates in 2023).
  • Variable Rates: Are directly tied to the prime rate set by the BOC. Your interest rate and monthly payment can fluctuate as the prime rate changes. This can be risky if rates rise but can be advantageous if they fall (historically, variable rates have been lower than fixed rates over the long term, but come with inherent volatility).

The 3 vs. 5 Year Lock-In Showdown

Once you've chosen between fixed and variable rates, the next decision is the length of your lock-in term. Here's a breakdown of the pros and cons of 3-year and 5-year fixed-rate mortgages in the current post-rate-cut environment:

3-Year Lock-In

  • Pros: Potential to capture further rate drops when you renew in 3 years, more flexibility for life changes or refinancing, acts as a buffer against short-term market fluctuations.
  • Cons: Slightly higher monthly payments compared to 5-year rates, potential to miss out on significant long-term rate decreases if they occur.

5-Year Lock-In

  • Pros: Lowest upfront interest rate (typically), peace of mind with stable and predictable payments for the entire term, protection against potential future rate hikes.
  • Cons: Less flexibility if you plan to sell or refinance within 5 years (early prepayment penalties can be higher), potentially missing out on beneficial rate drops in the coming years.

Beyond Fixed and Variable

  • Variable Rate with Interest Rate Differential (IRD): This option offers a variable rate that's typically lower than the standard variable rate (by around 0.10% to 0.25% currently) but with a set spread (IRD) added. It provides some savings compared to fixed rates (potentially saving thousands of dollars over the term) while offering some protection against significant rate hikes.
  • Prepayment Privileges: Consider the flexibility to make lump sum payments towards your mortgage principal. This can help you pay it off faster and save on interest. Some fixed-rate terms come with limitations on prepayments, while variable rates typically offer more freedom (prepayment penalties can range from 1-3% of the remaining mortgage balance on fixed rates).
  • Stress Test: Don't forget the stress test! All borrowers in Canada must qualify for a mortgage at a rate higher than the offered rate (typically 2% higher). This ensures you can handle potential future rate increases.

Numbers to Consider

  • Fixed Rate Spread: The difference between 3-year and 5-year rates is around 0.25% (as of June 2024).
  • Variable Rate vs. Fixed Rate: Variable rates are currently lower than both 3-year (by around 0.5%) and 5-year fixed rates (by around 0.75%). However, this can change depending on the BOC's future decisions.

Making an Informed Decision

The "best" option hinges on your individual circumstances. Here are some additional factors to consider:

  • Risk Tolerance: Are you comfortable with potential payment fluctuations inherent in variable rates? According to a 2023 RBC survey, 32% of Canadians are comfortable with variable rate fluctuations.
  • Market Predictions: Do you have an informed opinion on where interest rates might head in the next few years? Experts are currently predicting a gradual decrease in interest rates over the coming months, but economic forecasts can change.
  • Long-Term Plans: How long do you plan to stay in this home? Early prepayment penalties on fixed rates can be a factor if you plan to move soon (around 10% of Canadians sell their homes within the first 5 years).

Choosing Your Champion

By carefully considering your risk tolerance, financial goals, and market outlook, you can choose the lock-in term (fixed, variable, or a combination) that best positions you for success in this evolving mortgage environment. Here's a quick decision tree to help you navigate the key factors:

Do you prioritize stability and predictable payments?

  • Yes: Choose a 5-year fixed-rate or variable rate with IRD.

Do you think interest rates might fall further?

  • Yes: Consider a 3-year fixed rate or a variable rate.

Plan to sell or refinance soon?

  • Yes: A shorter lock-in term (3-year fixed or variable) might offer more flexibility.

Concerned about rising rates?

  • Yes: Opt for a longer lock-in term (5-year fixed) to shield yourself from potential increases.

Remember: This is just a starting point. Consulting a mortgage professional can help you tailor this decision tree to your specific needs and financial picture.

Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is intended for general educational purposes only and does not constitute financial or investment advice. Individual circumstances vary, and professional guidance is recommended before making any financial decisions. For personalized mortgage advice, please consult with a licensed mortgage broker in your area.

Subscribe to our email newsletter!

Thanks for joining our newsletter
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Related posts

Left Arrow
Left Arrow
Right Arrow
Right Arrow