The Canadian real estate industry is experiencing a significant shift following a major class action settlement that challenges traditional commission practices. This $7.8 million agreement represents the first crack in Canada's established real estate system and could reshape how transactions operate nationwide.

‍

Understanding the Class Action Lawsuit

A class action lawsuit representing home sellers from March 2010 to July 2025 alleges that mandatory commission structures violate Canada's Competition Act. The litigation, led by Mark Sunderland and Kevin McFall, targets the practice of requiring sellers to pay buyer agent commissions through the Multiple Listing Service (MLS) system.

The plaintiffs argue this system creates price-fixing by forcing sellers to compensate buyer agents, ultimately inflating home prices and reducing market competition. The lawsuit names several defendants, including the Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA) and various real estate boards.

‍

Historic Settlement Agreement

The first major settlement in this case involves a $7.8 million agreement that includes significant practice changes. The settling party agreed to pay this amount while denying any wrongdoing, stating the decision was made to eliminate litigation uncertainty.

Key aspects of the settlement include:

• Financial compensation of $7.8 million for affected sellers
• Cooperation with ongoing prosecution of non-settling parties
• Implementation of practice reforms
• Elimination of mandatory board membership requirements

The settlement requires court approval, with a hearing scheduled for October 6, 2025. Sellers who wish to opt out have until September 22, 2025, to do so.

‍

Current Commission Structure Under Scrutiny

Ontario's standard commission structure involves five percent of a home's sale price, typically split between buyer and seller agents. For Toronto's average home price of $1.14 million in January, this translates to approximately $57,000 in total commissions.

The lawsuit challenges the transparency of this system, arguing that buyers cannot negotiate their agent's commission directly since it's paid by the seller. This creates what plaintiffs describe as a lack of competition and inflated housing costs.

‍

Industry Response and Implications

The Canadian Real Estate Association maintains its position that the claims are without merit. CREA continues to defend against these allegations while supporting its members throughout the legal process.

This settlement could lead to several industry changes:

• Increased commission transparency
• More negotiable fee structures
• Changes to MLS participation requirements
• Potential elimination of mandatory board memberships

‍

Competition Bureau Investigation

The class action lawsuit coincides with an ongoing Competition Bureau investigation into commission rules and policies. In May 2025, the investigation expanded to include additional real estate organizations and MLS operators.

This dual pressure from both legal action and regulatory scrutiny suggests significant changes may be coming to Canada's organized real estate system.

‍

Impact on Home Buyers and Sellers

For consumers, this settlement could signal the beginning of more competitive commission structures. Potential changes include:

• Greater ability to negotiate buyer agent commissions
• Increased transparency in fee structures
• More options for commission payment arrangements
• Potential reduction in overall transaction costs

However, experts caution that immediate changes may be limited. The settlement only applies to specific sellers, and the broader industry continues to operate under existing structures while defending against ongoing litigation.

‍

Looking Forward

This settlement represents the first significant challenge to Canada's traditional real estate commission system. While the settling party continues to deny wrongdoing, the agreement to pay $7.8 million and implement practice changes suggests recognition that the current system faces substantial challenges.

As the class action lawsuit continues against remaining defendants, the real estate industry may need to adapt to new competitive pressures and regulatory requirements. For consumers, this could mean more choices and potentially lower costs when buying or selling homes.

The final impact will depend on court approval of the settlement, the outcome of ongoing litigation against other defendants, and how the Competition Bureau's investigation concludes. What's certain is that Canada's real estate industry is entering a period of significant change that could benefit consumers through increased competition and transparency.

‍

This settlement is subject to court approval. Home sellers affected by this case should consult with legal counsel to understand their rights and options.

‍
Source: Residential Real Estate Buyer Brokerage Commissions Class Action